If you're in Middlesex County, New Jersey, and you're craving something sweet, you're in luck! This area is home to a variety of dessert spots, offering everything from ice cream and cupcakes to custom cakes and macarons. Whether you're a local or just visiting, you'll definitely want to explore these must-try dessert locations. Let’s dive into the best ice cream and dessert spots in Middlesex County!
1. Sweet New Creations
Rated 4.7/5 with 31 reviews, Sweet New Creations is a local gem for anyone with a sweet tooth. This bakery specializes in custom cakes and cupcakes, with their tres leches cupcake being a fan favorite. The owner, Daisy, is known for her exceptional customer service and passion for baking, making this spot a top pick for both special events and everyday cravings.
Highlights: Cupcakes, custom cakes, great service.
Why Go? Their desserts are made with love, and the staff goes the extra mile to ensure you have a delightful experience. It’s also a great spot to grab a quick treat if you’re in the area!
2. La Bon Bake Shoppes
If you're in the mood for more traditional bakery desserts, La Bon Bake Shoppes (4.2/5, 63 reviews) should be on your list. Famous for their delicious birthday cakes and pastries, this charming bakery also offers a wide selection of other treats. Whether you’re celebrating or just indulging in something sweet, La Bon Bake Shoppes never disappoints.
Highlights: Birthday cakes, pastries, and desserts.
Why Go? A reliable spot for custom cakes and special occasions. They’re known for their consistent quality and friendly service.
3. Nothing Bundt Cakes
If Bundt cakes are your thing, Nothing Bundt Cakes (4.5/5, 81 reviews) is a must-visit. This chain bakery specializes in Bundt cakes that are both moist and delicious. They also offer seasonal flavors, so there's always something new to try. Their customer service is top-notch, and they even accept expired coupons for extra brownie points!
Highlights: Bundt cakes, seasonal flavors.
Why Go? You’ll find high-quality cakes with a variety of flavors and consistent service.
4. Yo Dessert
For a sweet and cool treat, Yo Dessert (4.8/5, 5 reviews) is the place to go! This ice cream and frozen yogurt spot is perfect for anyone who loves trying different frozen desserts. With a menu filled with unique offerings, Yo Dessert ensures there’s something for everyone.
Highlights: Ice cream, frozen yogurt, drinks.
Why Go? It’s a fun and unique spot to try a variety of frozen treats, from classic ice cream to inventive new flavors.
5. Itzy Bitzy Patisserie
If you’re a fan of fine pastries, Itzy Bitzy Patisserie (5.0/5, 2 reviews) will blow you away. Known for serving some of the best macarons in the NYC area, this patisserie is a true gem for anyone who appreciates fine French desserts. With a pastry chef trained under Pierre Herme of Paris, the quality is second to none.
Highlights: Macarons, French pastries.
Why Go? If you're craving a taste of Paris, this is your go-to spot in Middlesex County!
6. The Bake Shop
Located in a friendly neighborhood, The Bake Shop (4.3/5, 3 reviews) offers a variety of baked goods including cupcakes and cakes. Customers rave about the helpful staff and the recommendations they give when you’re unsure of what to pick.
Highlights: Cupcakes, baked goods, great service.
Why Go? The welcoming atmosphere and tasty treats make this an excellent choice for a sweet snack or a special dessert for your next gathering.
7. House of Cupcakes
With an average rating of 3.6/5 and 244 reviews, House of Cupcakes is a popular spot for those who love a good cupcake. Though reviews are mixed, this place is known for a wide variety of cupcake flavors and classic bakery staples.
Highlights: Cupcakes, cakes, cookies.
Why Go? It’s a reliable spot for classic cupcake varieties and a quick dessert fix.
8. Sunmerry Bakery
Sunmerry Bakery (4.4/5, 261 reviews) is a cute dessert spot that doubles as a coffee and tea haven. Located in the 99 Ranch Plaza, they offer an assortment of cakes and bubble tea that are perfect for any occasion.
Highlights: Specialty cakes, bubble tea.
Why Go? It’s a great place for grabbing a quick treat, especially if you love bubble tea and unique cakes.
9. Brownstone Pancake Factory
Although Brownstone Pancake Factory (4.1/5, 140 reviews) is primarily known for its pancakes and burgers, their dessert menu is worth checking out. Whether you're stopping by for brunch or just for a sweet indulgence, they offer a variety of tasty dessert options.
Highlights: Pancakes, burgers, desserts.
Why Go? Perfect for those who want a variety of meals, including some tasty desserts.
10. Laffair II Bake Shop
With a rating of 3.4/5 and 69 reviews, Laffair II Bake Shop offers great bakery items. Although it’s a bit of a mixed bag in terms of customer reviews, their desserts look as good as they taste.
Highlights: Bakery treats, cakes, cupcakes.
Why Go? A good spot for grabbing your favorite baked goods, though service and variety may vary.
FAQs About Ice Cream Stores in Middlesex
1. Where can I find the best ice cream in Middlesex County?
You can’t go wrong with Yo Dessert and Blizzard Island, both offering delicious frozen treats, including Italian ice and hard ice cream.
2. Are there any dessert places that offer delivery?
Yes! Many dessert spots like Nothing Bundt Cakes and Brownstone Pancake Factory offer delivery, so you can enjoy their sweet offerings from the comfort of your home.
3. What’s the best place for cupcakes in Middlesex?
For cupcakes, head to House of Cupcakes or Sweet New Creations. Both have unique flavors and great customer service.
4. Is there a place that offers both ice cream and bubble tea?
Sunmerry Bakery is your go-to spot if you want a combination of cakes, bubble tea, and sweet treats.
5. Can I find custom cakes in Middlesex?
Yes, Sweet New Creations and La Bon Bake Shoppes are excellent choices for custom cakes for all occasions.
Conclusion
Whether you're looking for a quick ice cream cone, a custom cake, or some delicate macarons, Middlesex County has something to satisfy every dessert craving. With a variety of bakeries, ice cream shops, and patisseries, you’ll always find a sweet spot to treat yourself or celebrate special moments.
Don’t wait—grab your friends or family, head out, and try these delicious dessert spots today!
#MiddlesexEats #DessertLovers #IceCreamInMiddlesex #SweetTreats #MiddlesexNJ